Prosecutorial bias is a significant issue within the criminal justice system, often leading to unfair trials and wrongful convictions. This post aims to explain what prosecutorial bias is, provide real-life examples, and offer guidance on what a defendant can do if they suspect bias. We’ll also look at relevant case law that can be cited in motions to recuse a biased prosecutor.

What is Prosecutorial Bias?

Prosecutorial bias occurs when a prosecutor allows personal beliefs, relationships, or interests to influence their decisions in a criminal case. This bias can manifest in various ways, such as:

1. Selective Prosecution: Targeting certain individuals or groups unfairly.
2. Improper Influence: Allowing outside interests to affect prosecutorial decisions.
3. Prejudicial Statements: Making statements that could influence the jury against the defendant.

Case Law Examples of Prosecutorial Bias

Now, lets consider some actual instances where prosecutorial bias has been addressed in the law:

Selective Prosecution

Selective prosecution occurs when a prosecutor targets an individual based on arbitrary or discriminatory criteria, such as race, religion, or political beliefs, rather than the merits of the case.

A case example of selective prosecution can be found in Yick Wo v. Hopkins, 6 S.Ct. 1064 (1886). In this case, the Supreme Court held that a law applied in a discriminatory manner violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The case involved Chinese laundry workers who were denied permits, while non-Chinese owners were granted permits under the same law. This landmark decision underscores that selective prosecution based on race is unconstitutional.

Improper Influence

Prosecutors must remain impartial and avoid any conflicts of interest. When they allow outside influences, such as personal relationships or political pressure, to affect their decisions, it undermines the fairness of the judicial process.

A case example of improper influence can be found in Young v. United States ex rel. Vuitton et Fils S.A., 107 S.Ct. 2124 (1987). In this case, the Supreme Court held that a prosecutor with a personal interest in the outcome of a case should be disqualified. The decision highlighted the need for prosecutors to avoid conflicts of interest to maintain the integrity of the legal process.

Prejudicial Statements

Prosecutors should refrain from making statements that could prejudice the jury against the defendant. Such statements can lead to an unfair trial.

A case example of prejudicial prosecutor statements can be found in Berger v. United States, 55 S.Ct 629 (1935). In this case, the Supreme Court overturned a conviction due to prosecutorial misconduct, including improper statements that prejudiced the jury. This case emphasized the importance of maintaining professional conduct and avoiding prejudicial comments.

What to Do If You Suspect Prosecutorial Bias

If you believe that prosecutorial bias is affecting your case, there are several steps you can take:

1. Document Everything: Keep detailed records of any instances or actions that suggest bias. This documentation will be crucial if you need to file a motion to recuse the prosecutor.
2. Consult with Your Attorney: Discuss your concerns with your attorney. They can provide legal advice on the best course of action and help you understand the potential impact of prosecutorial bias in your case.
3. File a Motion For Recusal: If there is substantial evidence of bias, your attorney or you can file a motion to recuse the prosecutor. This motion requests that the court remove the biased prosecutor from your case and appoint a neutral one. In your motion, cite relevant case law to support your argument. For example, you could reference Yick Wo v. Hopkins, Young v. United States, or Berger v. United States to illustrate the impact of prosecutorial bias and the need for impartiality.

My Final Thoughts

Prosecutorial bias can severely undermine the fairness of a trial and lead to wrongful convictions. By understanding what prosecutorial bias is, recognizing its signs, and taking appropriate legal action, defendants can protect their rights and seek a fair trial. If you suspect prosecutorial bias in your case, its crucial to document the instances, consult with your attorney, and consider filing a motion for recusal. Citing relevant case law can strengthen your motion and helps ensure that justice is served impartially.

If you, or someone you know, will be engaging in self-representation in a criminal matter or is pursuing any form of post-conviction relief following a criminal conviction, our book, The Colossal Book of Criminal Citations, is a crucial tool in the pursuit of justice. Order your copy today, or on behalf of someone incarcerated. Our books are softcover, institution friendly, and ready for immediate shipping.