When someone is facing criminal charges, the court may allow character letters as part of the sentencing process. Knowing how to write a character letter is an important consideration for loved ones and friends of the defendant. A character letter is a formal letter written on behalf of the defendant by someone who knows them well and can speak to their character, behavior, and qualities. These letters aim to present a more balanced picture of the defendant, beyond the crime they are accused of, and may influence the judge’s final sentencing decision

If you are tasked with writing a character letter to a judge for sentencing, your letter could play a pivotal role in the outcome. Writing such a letter requires care and attention to detail, as it needs to be both respectful and professional. Below is a comprehensive guide for how to write a character letter, along with tips on what should be included.

Why Write a Character Letter?

A character letter offers the judge a chance to see the defendant’s personality, history, and contributions to society outside the courtroom. It can humanize the individual, demonstrating remorse, personal growth, and other qualities that might not be evident from the charges alone. These letters can be influential, especially if the judge is weighing the severity of a sentence or deciding between options such as probation, community service, or incarceration.

Basic Guidelines for How to Write a Character Letter

Here are the basic guidelines on how to write a character letter:

• Be Respectful and Professional: The tone of your letter should be respectful and professional. Remember, you are writing to a judge who is handling a legal case. Keep the language formal, avoid slang, and make sure the letter is polite throughout.
• Use Proper Letter Format: Just like any formal letter, a character reference letter should follow a proper format containing:
• Header: Include your name, address, phone number, and email at the top (if not using letterhead).
• Date: Write the date of the letter, below your contact information.
• Salutation: Address the letter to “The Honorable [Judge’s Name],” using their full title.
• Body: This is where you include the core of your letter, broken down into several sections.
• Closing: Close the letter with a respectful phrase such as “Sincerely” or “Respectfully.”
• Signature: Sign your name at the bottom of the letter, and include your contact information underneath.
• Stick to the Facts: Avoid unnecessary embellishment or exaggeration. The purpose is to present a truthful and honest view of the defendant’s character. Stick to what you know about the individual and avoid hearsay and secondhand information.
• Keep it Concise: The letter should be clear and to the point, typically no longer than one or two pages. Judges are often dealing with multiple cases, so it’s important to present your points in a succinct and organized manner.

What to Include in the Character Letter

When learning how to write a character letter, it’s important to understand what to include in the letter. It’s important to include specific details that speak to the defendant’s character and life history. Here are some key components to consider:

1. Your Relationship to the Defendant

Begin by introducing yourself and explaining how you know the defendant. Provide context about your relationship such as how long you’ve known the individual, in what capacity you know them (e.g., family member, friend, employer, neighbor, teacher). Explain the nature of your relationship. Is it personal, professional, or both. Be specific about your experience with the individual. If you’ve known them for many years and have seen them in different situations, explain how that has shaped your view of their character.

2. Defendant’s Positive Qualities

Discuss the defendant’s positive traits that make them a good person, such as their honesty. Share examples where they demonstrated integrity or truthfulness. Discuss their empathy and compassion. Describe how they show kindness to others, or help those in need. Detail their hard work. Provide evidence of their commitment to their job, education, or personal growth.

Consider describing their community involvement. Mention any volunteer work or contributions to the community. Explain their family responsibilities if applicable. Highlight their role as a parent, spouse, or caregiver, showing their dedication to family.

You want to portray the defendant as a well-rounded individual who has made positive contributions to society.

3. Acknowledgement of the Crime

Address the crime in a respectful and truthful way. The defendant should not be portrayed as someone without fault. It is important to acknowledge that the defendant is facing charges and that they’ve made a mistake. If the defendant has expressed remorse or taken steps to address their behavior (e.g., seeking counseling, or attending rehabilitation programs), include that information.

However, avoid making excuses for their behavior. The focus should be on their willingness to take responsibility, learn from the situation, and grow as a person.

4. Character Transformation or Remorse

If relevant, mention any changes in the defendant’s character or actions since the incident. For example, have they shown remorse or taken steps to make amends for their actions? Have they sought therapy joined support groups, or demonstrated other forms of personal growth? Have they worked to repair relationships damaged by the incident?

This demonstrates that the defendant is not only aware of their mistake but is actively working to become a better person.

5. Potential for Rehabilitation or Support

Speak to the defendant’s potential for rehabilitation and growth. This can be particularly important for cases involving first-time offenders or individuals who have shown genuine remorse. You might want to mention as many positive steps they’ve taken toward rehabilitation, such as their enrollment in a rehabilitation program (e.g., drug or alcohol counseling).

Detail how the defendant is engaging in community service or taking responsibility for others impacted by their actions. Describe the defendant’s support from their family and friends, highlighting the stability and care system around them.

By emphasizing the defendant’s commitment to change, you are reinforcing their readiness for rehabilitation and the importance of supporting them through the legal process.

6. How the Defendant Affects Those Around Them

Illustrate the positive impact the defendant has on others. This might include how they are a good role model for children or peers or how they have helped others in difficult times. Share how their absence would affect family members, employees, or other community members.

This shows the judge that the defendant’s contributions to others are meaningful and that their presence in the community has value.

Final Considerations

Before sending the letter, make sure it is:

• Proofread: Check for any spelling, grammar, or punctuation errors.
• Tailored: Ensure the content of the letter is relevant to the judge and the case at hand.
• Signed: If possible, sign the letter physically (if it is being submitted in paper form), as this adds authenticity and weight to the letter.

If you’re unsure about the contents of the letter, it can be helpful to consult with the defendant’s attorney for advice. Attorneys can guide you on the legal importance of the letter and ensure that it complies with any court guidelines.

My Final Thoughts

Learning how to write a character letter is an important task if you have a friend or loved one being sentenced in a criminal case. The words you choose on behalf of a defendant can impact the judge’s final decision. Remember, the judge only knows the defendant based on the evidence presented in the courtroom. Your letter can expand the judge’s knowledge, helping sway important factors when considering a sentence for the defendant.

By following these guidelines, you can craft a well written and impactful character letter that may assist in the defendant’s sentencing process.

If you, or someone you know, will be proceeding to trial, challenging a criminal sentence, pursuing post-conviction relief, or litigating a Civil Rights Section 1983 lawsuit, our books are crucial resources in the pursuit of justice. Purchase your copy today, or on behalf of someone incarcerated who may have seen our advertisement in Prison Legal News magazine.